Etsy vs Shopify fees: marketplace or your own store

This site participates in affiliate programs. If you sign up through a link on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

By Jason Feng, Founder & Researcher. See how this review was researched.

Quick answer

Etsy and Shopify do not have comparable fee structures, and that is the whole story. Etsy charges no subscription and takes a cut of every sale: a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee, and a 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee on US sales. Shopify charges $29/month billed yearly on Basic and takes 2.9% + 30¢ per order. The break-even sits around $400 to $430 in monthly sales, or roughly 4 to 20 orders depending on your average order value. Below that, Etsy costs less. Above it, Shopify does, and the gap widens with volume. What Etsy’s fee buys is marketplace traffic, which the fee table cannot price.

Table of contents

Three short even stacks of plain metal discs on a white desk

Two different fee models

Etsy is a marketplace. Buyers come to Etsy, search for a product, and find your shop among millions of others. Etsy charges you for access to that demand, per listing and per sale, and it charges nothing to open the shop.

Shopify is software. You build the store, you bring the traffic, and you pay a flat subscription whether you sell one item or ten thousand. The card rate applies per order, but there is no per-listing cost and no percentage of your sale going to the platform for the privilege of listing.

That difference decides which one is cheaper at a given size, and it also decides whether the comparison is fair. A store with no audience pays nothing on Etsy until it sells. The same store pays $29 on Shopify in month one regardless.

What Etsy charges on a US sale

Etsy publishes its seller fees on both its seller page and its help center. These are the US numbers, captured on 2026-10-01:

Etsy fee Amount When it applies
Listing fee $0.20 per listing On publish, sold or not; listings last four months
Auto-renew after sale $0.20 When an auto-renewed listing sells
Multi-quantity listing $0.20 per extra item When a buyer takes more than one variation from a listing
Transaction fee 6.5% On the total order amount, including shipping and gift wrap
Payment processing 3% + $0.25 Per Etsy Payments transaction, US bank accounts
Currency conversion 2.5% When listing currency differs from your payment account currency

Etsy also states that a one-time shop set-up fee may apply, and that the amount due appears before you finish setting up the shop. It does not publish that amount on the fee page, so a new seller should expect to see it at checkout rather than in advance.

The transaction fee is the one people underestimate. It applies to the whole order amount, not the item price alone. If you charge $8 for shipping, the 6.5% applies to that $8 too. On a $50 order with free shipping, it is $3.25. On the same order with $8 shipping and $3 gift wrap, it is $3.97.

Then there is Etsy’s Regulatory Operating fee. Etsy charges it in specific countries, and the United States is not on the list. Sellers based in Canada, France, Italy, Spain, the UK, and a handful of others see an added percentage on item price plus shipping, ranging from 0.05% in India to 1.97% in Hungary. If your bank account is not in one of those countries, that line does not apply to you.

What Shopify charges on a US sale

Shopify’s fee stack is a subscription plus a card rate. These are the US numbers from the pricing page, captured on 2026-10-01:

Shopify plan Billed monthly Billed yearly Standard card rate Third-party transaction fee
Basic $39/mo $29/mo 2.9% + 30¢ 2%
Grow $105/mo $79/mo 2.7% + 30¢ 1%
Advanced $399/mo $299/mo 2.5% + 30¢ 0.6%
Plus Starts at $2,300/mo Not published 2.25% + 30¢ 0.2%

Two lines matter for the Etsy comparison.

The first is the card rate, which falls as the plan gets more expensive. Breaking even on the Basic-to-Grow upgrade takes about $300,000 in annual card volume, because $50 a month divided by a 0.2-point rate drop lands there.

The second is the third-party transaction fee. If you use a processor other than Shopify Payments, Shopify charges Basic users 2% of the order on top of that processor’s own rate. Etsy has no equivalent line, and it is the single biggest hidden cost on the Shopify side for anyone who cannot use Shopify Payments.

Shopify also caps free marketplace order syncing at 50 orders a month, then charges 1% up to a $99 monthly cap. A store that sells through Amazon or eBay alongside its own site should price that in. Our WooCommerce vs Shopify fee comparison works through the same third-party fee from the self-hosted side.

The break-even point

Set the two cost structures against each other, order by order.

Etsy’s variable cost per order is 6.5% + 3% + $0.25, plus $0.20 in listing fees if each order corresponds to a fresh listing. That is 9.5% of the order plus $0.45. Shopify Basic is $29/month plus 2.9% plus 30¢.

The monthly sales level where they meet:

Average order value Break-even monthly sales Orders at break-even
$20 $395 20
$30 $409 14
$50 $420 8
$100 $430 4

The formula behind the table is $29 ÷ (0.066 + 0.15 ÷ AOV). The 0.066 is the percentage difference between Etsy’s 9.5% and Shopify’s 2.9%. The 0.15 is the difference between Etsy’s $0.45 in fixed per-order costs and Shopify’s $0.30.

Read it as a floor, not a verdict. A handmade seller doing 6 orders a month at $60 each is under $400 and Etsy is genuinely cheaper in cash terms. The same seller at 15 orders a month is already past the line.

The table also assumes every Etsy order carries its own listing fee. A seller with multi-quantity listings spreads $0.20 across several sales, which pushes the break-even down slightly in Shopify’s favor. A made-to-order seller pays it every time.

One number the model leaves out entirely is Offsite Ads, and it can swamp everything above.

Total cost at the same revenue

Here is the same comparison as a monthly bill, using a $50 average order value and a store that sells only through its own checkout on the Shopify side.

Monthly sales Orders Etsy total Shopify Basic Shopify Grow
$2,500 50 $260 $117 $162
$10,000 200 $1,040 $379 $409
$50,000 1,000 $5,200 $1,679 $1,629

The Shopify column uses the card rate for each plan and yearly billing for the subscription. The Etsy column includes the transaction fee, payment processing, and one $0.20 listing fee per order.

The gap is not close at volume. At $50,000 a month, Etsy’s fees run a little over three times what Shopify Grow costs, and Shopify’s rate would still be falling if you moved to Advanced. That is the structural consequence of a per-sale cut against a subscription.

What the table cannot show is where the buyers come from. Etsy’s $5,200 at that volume is paid on sales the platform helped generate. Shopify’s $1,729 is paid on sales you have to generate yourself, and for a small business with no audience, the cost of getting there can exceed the fee difference. If you are weighing platforms on more than fees, our small business platform picks break the decision down by SKU count, order volume, and technical ability.

The fees neither page puts in the headline

Three lines deserve attention before you pick.

Offsite Ads is the largest. Etsy advertises your listings on Google, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and partner sites, and charges 15% of any order attributed to one of those ads when your shop has made under $10,000 in any 365-day period. Cross that line and the rate drops to 12%, but enrollment becomes mandatory for the life of the shop. Etsy caps the fee at $100 per order. On a $50 order, a single offsite-attributed sale costs $7.50, which is more than the entire monthly subscription gap between the two platforms. Orders are attributed when a buyer clicks an ad and buys within 30 days.

Shopify’s third-party transaction fee is the second. On Basic it is 2% of the order when you use a processor other than Shopify Payments, and Shopify Payments is available only in certain countries. A merchant outside its footprint pays both Stripe’s rate and Shopify’s 2%, which on a $50 order is $1.45 to Stripe plus $1.00 to Shopify.

The third is the fixed per-order fee, and it cuts against Etsy surprisingly. Shopify charges 30¢ per order and Etsy charges 25¢, so at high order counts Shopify pays 5¢ more per sale. That difference is real but small next to the 6.6 points of percentage that separate them.

Etsy’s pricing also lacks a published ceiling on what the percentages apply to. Shopify’s pricing page, by contrast, publishes the plan caps and the marketplace sync cap in the same table as the rates. When one vendor publishes limits and the other does not, treat the omission as a reason to ask, not as evidence of a limit.

Our verdict

Start on Etsy if you are validating a product and your monthly sales sit under roughly $400. The fee structure charges you nothing until you sell, the marketplace brings buyers you have not built, and the $0.20 listing cost is small enough to test a catalog. Watch the Offsite Ads line, because a shop that crosses $10,000 in a 365-day window gives up the opt-out permanently.

Move to Shopify when you clear the break-even and the store becomes the business. At $10,000 in monthly sales, Shopify Basic costs about $379 against Etsy’s $1,040, and the difference is roughly the cost of an entry-level ad budget you would need to replace Etsy’s traffic anyway. If you will use Shopify Payments, the card rate falls further as you grow, which Etsy’s never does.

The verdict I would give a friend: run both, and treat Etsy as a customer acquisition channel rather than a store. The listing fee and the transaction fee are the price of demand, and for a small business that is often a better deal than paying for ads. The mistake is staying there at a volume where the 6.5% has already outgrown the audience it buys.

Before you commit, run your own numbers through the full fee comparison across platforms and check your platform against the four-platform pricing model, which covers the GMV caps Etsy and Shopify both avoid.

How we researched this

  • This is a research-based review. Every figure comes from the vendors’ own published pricing pages, seller fee pages, and help center articles, which we link and date.
  • We captured the Etsy seller page and fee documentation, and the Shopify pricing page, on 2026-10-01 through a US exit IP with an en-US locale. Every rate here is the US version.
  • Etsy’s payment processing table varies by bank country; we used the United States row and name the other regions only where they change the conclusion.
  • Break-even figures are our arithmetic on published rates, shown as a formula so you can substitute your own average order value.
  • Where a vendor does not publish a number, we say so instead of estimating. Our full methodology is on the how we research page.

Sources

  • https://www.etsy.com/sell (accessed 2026-10-01)
  • https://help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/360035902374-Etsy-Fee-Basics (accessed 2026-10-01)
  • https://help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/115015628847-What-are-Payment-Processing-Fees-for-Selling-on-Etsy (accessed 2026-10-01)
  • https://help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000338367-How-Etsy-s-Offsite-Ads-Work (accessed 2026-10-01)
  • https://help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000344668-Currency-Conversion-Fees (accessed 2026-10-01)
  • https://help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/1500011073202-What-is-a-Regulatory-Operating-Fee (accessed 2026-10-01)
  • https://www.shopify.com/pricing (accessed 2026-10-01)

Leave a Comment